Despite solidifying herself as a Night One villain on Season 23 of The Bachelor, DJ Catherine Agro didn't live up to fans' expectations after she memorably arrived at the mansion with her dog Lucy.

Catherine Agro brought her dog with her on The Bachelor, asking Colton Underwood to watch her pet as she competed for his heart on the show. While some contestants thought it was bold of her, it was ...

It has long been a national disgrace that the Bachelor mansion does not have a house dog, but for a few glorious moments during this season's premiere, that pup-sized hole in our hearts was filled.